How Did the Tomatoes Do?

We had 14 different tomato varieties and one tomatillo in the Demo Garden this summer. (Yes, they’re still growing, but I don’t think my analysis is going to change in the next month.) Some of them were clear winners, others had good and bad points. Of course, because we only had one plant of each variety, this is a very anecdotal analysis and not remotely close to scientific research. You can take this with a grain of salt when determining what you want to plant next year.

Celebrity – Actually, I was really disappointed in Celebrity. It cracks terribly…it was much worse about cracking than the heirlooms, which is pretty impressive! We lost a number of tomatoes because they were so badly cracked that they rotted on the plant while not even close to ripe. Yuck! Yield was decent. Flavor was decent. The plant is pretty healthy, so it is blooming again and setting new tomatoes for the fall, which is a plus.

Brandywine – While the flavor of this heirloom was good, the 4 or 5 tomatoes we got was not super impressive. It was also very late producing and the first plant to get any Early Blight. It is still alive and I think there are some flowers on it, but I’m not holding my breath for more tomatoes. Cracking wasn’t bad, maybe because it was dry by the time it started ripening fruit.

Orange Blossom

Orange Blossom – VERY early producer, but horrible cracking! Terrible! Worse than Celebrity! Fruit were on the small side, and the orange fruit were mild, almost bland. After the initial production, there weren’t any fruit for the rest of the summer, although there are a few flowers again now.

Sweet Seedless – Surprisingly, this one had a decent yield of moderate to small tomatoes that actually tasted quite

Sweet Seedless

good. I don’t recall any cracking (remember how scientific I said this all was?), and of course it sports no seeds in the locular gel. (Um, yeah…”locular gel” is the jelly-like part that the seeds are in. It’s one of those terms that we horticulture folk like to trot out occasionally.) It has pretty much petered out on the production.

JTO-99197 – This variety’s claim to fame is that it is supposedly resistant to Early Blight, one of our biggest foliar disease issues. It didn’t have a bad case of Early Blight, but that doesn’t mean much, since only the Brandywine had enough Early Blight to be an issue. We really didn’t have enough disease this year to make it a decent test. It was also a later producer, which isn’t necessarily bad if you plant some earlier producers too. I wouldn’t consider the yield spectacular and the tomatoes didn’t seem to crack much. They were pretty hard – uh, firm, and I don’t think I managed to taste one of these when I actually knew for sure which variety it was.

Sunmaster – This is one of two varieties we tried that supposedly can set fruit under high heat conditions. While we

Sunmaster (Top) & 2 Solar Fire (Bottom)

had plenty of high heat conditions this summer, the problem is that this is a determinate variety. Meaning it grew, then flowered and set fruit, and then all the tomatoes ripened. It wasn’t actually trying to set tomatoes during our interminable weeks of hot weather, so it doesn’t have any tomatoes on it now, but that doesn’t mean it wouldn’t have set during the heat, just that it finished that phase of its life before that trait was needed. All that said, it had good yield and definitely the largest fruit of the hybrid varieties. Very firm, no cracking. Average flavor. Later producing.

Solar Fire – Other heat set variety, same as above but with slightly smaller tomatoes. (More like Celebrity in size.) Later producing.

Brandymaster & Rose

Brandymaster Red – Hybrid version of Brandywine. Much earlier, in fact, one of the earliest varieties. However, it cracked horribly (not quite as bad as Celebrity, but close). Although the plant grew like an indeterminate, it produced more like a determinate, with lots of tomatoes early, and none since then. I didn’t care though, because the tomatoes weren’t that tasty.  I would rather have 5 Brandywine tomatoes all summer than 15 of these.

Rose – Another heirloom that was reputed to be very similar to Brandywine. Later than the earlier hybrids, but about the same as JTO99197, Solar Fire, and Sunmaster. Much earlier than Brandywine, but with the same pretty pink color. These were slightly smaller than the Brandywine tomatoes and they didn’t exhibit any catfacing (the twisted, contorted shapes on the blossom end that many heirlooms exhibit), which I was surprised by. The fruit didn’t crack either, which was a pleasant surprise. This was also the clear winner in flavor this year. Yum! Yield was decent for an heirloom – I think 8 tomatoes on a single plant.

Sweet Cluster

Sweet Cluster – This is a smaller “cluster” tomato (think the ones you get “on the vine” at the grocery store). It was pretty early to start producing and is still producing. It was pretty consistent in having a few tomatoes every week. The tomatoes were quite small, and only the first couple weeks did we have easily definable “clusters.” No cracking and above average to good flavor.

Chocolate Cherry

Chocolate Cherry – We had this purple/brown cherry tomato last year, and it was excellent both years. Heavy production on a single plant, tomatoes didn’t get smaller through the season, no breaks in production, no cracking, great flavor. I’m a huge fan of this tomato.

SunCherry – Another cherry tomato we had last year and again this year. It is supposed to be very early, but apparently a nutrient deficiency or something delayed production this year. Tasty, but the fruit get tiny after the midpoint of the season. I mean REALLY tiny.  It was also our only tomato plant to get spider mites this year. Not sure what that was about.

RFT-6153 – A field production variety that the Master Gardeners grew to great acclaim 3 or 4 years ago, which tons of tomatoes ripening all at once. It definitely wasn’t that good this year, but it does have nearly mature green tomatoes on it right now, which means that it set some fruit while it was still beastly hot. That is impressive. Average size, pretty firm, average flavor. Minimal cracking.

4th of July – Very popular home garden variety that is an early producer. Like Sweet Cluster, it has small fruit and it produced pretty consistently throughout the summer. Good flavor, minimal cracking.


Toma Verde Tomatillo – My first time growing a true tomatillo, and it had tons of flowers early. It took awhile to set fruit and become productive, and overall, it wasn’t as productive as I thought it should be. It tasted like a tomatillo…I’m not enough of a connoisseur to tell you anything more than that. I also thought the tomatillos were a bit on the small side for my expectations.

That’s all I have to say about our tomatoes this year! Pretty much a mixed bag this year, although the smaller-fruited varieties definitely did better than the larger-fruited varieties. Of the hybrids, if I had to pick a winner it would probably be the RFT-6153 (although I personally don’t think it compares well to some of the other common hybrids that we didn’t grow). I really liked the Rose, but I will give the heirlooms a break on yield if they taste great. As I said, I’d rather have 6 tomatoes I really enjoy than a bushel that I will only eat after making them into spaghetti sauce. (Unless my intention is to can spaghetti sauce, which is another discussion.)

What tomatoes (if any) did well for you this year?

About Rebecca

I'm a Horticulture Educator with Sedgwick County Extension, a branch of K-State Research and Extension, located in Wichita, KS. I teach about fruits, vegetables, and herbs.

Posted on September 14, 2010, in Around the Garden and tagged . Bookmark the permalink. 6 Comments.

  1. Your description of celebrity is right on! I had very similar results.

  2. I think it was a bad year for tomatillos… mine survived, barely, but weren’t productive. More tellingly, the ones in the community garden did much worse than last year, despite regular watering.

    The JetStars, especially the one in the Smart Pot, did much better than expected given the weather. There were a couple of breaks in production, but not bad. They weren’t as productive as JetStars usually are, and ended up with smaller fruit, but all things considered (I don’t have an irrigation setup) I can’t complain. They’re blossoming like crazy right now, so they have no lack of optimism.

    The Romas (La Roma, specifically) were very late, waiting out the heat, but just when I’d given up on them they finally started producing and absolutely went gangbusters. Saw just a little blossom-end rot here recently, but that’s been their only problem. They didn’t even care that it was too hot to restake them and they ended sprawling half in the mulch.

  3. My Italian Heirloom has done really well. It stopped blossoming during the heat, but once that let up it set a lot more fruit. The later ones are about half the size of the early ones, but very flavorful. I’m definitely growing them again.

    The Sungold, well, I finally had to chop it down cause of spider mites, but despite the fact that 95% of it was dead, the very tips were still blossoming and setting fruit. I’m pretty sure the pot it’s in is going to have volunteers next year since I couldn’t keep up with its production. Even through the heat. This is definitely the tomato for people who want an easy-to-grow plant. I never even fertilized it and forgot to water it NUMEROUS times during the heat.

    The Supersteak hybrid was disappointing. So much of its production went into the vines, even though I barely gave it any nitrogen. I only got 5 tomatoes off it, and they were a smidge on the tart side for me. Won’t grow again.

    • Oooh…maybe we’ll have to try the Italian heirloom next year! Is it more of a roma type or a regular round type?

      • The seed packet described it them as huge and weighing over a pound. The first round I got were mostly round, some with a little nipple on the blossom-end. These last ones are more in an oxheart shape. And it was really early too! I transplated mine on May 18 and got the first tomato July 20.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: